Tim Dawson (10/17/2014)
Certainly liability is a big concern. We're a very popular product and our exposure is high. The trouble with fuel estimation (and we had a lengthy discussion in the office about this yesterday) is that we don't actually know how you're flying the plane. We know what your plans were, but people often don't stick to the plan. You might be flying with a much higher power setting, you might have done more climbing, you might have been flying into much more of a headwind than was forecast. At the end of the day, you might have a lot less fuel than we say you have. I'd much rather not say anything. I don't think we'll be moving from that stance regarding fuel estimation.OK, I can sort of understand where you're coming from even though I don't share your opinion entirely.
The trouble with having "real" values for the current leg is that we're then showing differently-sourced values for one leg than we are for the other boxes under the same column. I do like the metaphor of a plan turning into a log, but I'm not sure how obvious that metaphor would be to everybody else. Some columns do not particularly lend themselves to this either. It's like we'd be trying to replace the boxes of the current leg in the PLOG by duplicating our actual instruments which of course are available elsewhere.
I see no problem with "differently-sourced" values in the PLOG. Let's just step back and put ourselves into the shoes of the pilot. You look at the PLOG and now, in one glance, have a full overview of what's been, what is, and what's planned to be. That's exactly what I would like to see. Yes, some of the instrument values from the map page will show up in the PLOG as well. So what? They are important values and you see them in a different context on the PLOG. There it shows you the history, present and future of these values. Is the headwind stronger than planned? If so, I can see that effect directly from the PLOG because future ETAs will be updated according to the flight's progress. I can print the PLOG after the flight, if so desired, and have a good record of what happened. Printing it before the flight gives me a record of what was planned.
-- Chris.